Skip to content
NOMADE.Real Estate / ConnecticutSay hello
Menu

$1,200,000

Closed

25 Johnny Cake Hill Road

Old Lyme, Connecticut, 06371 · New London County

4

Beds

4

Baths

2,750

Sq Ft

1730

Built

MLS # 24095314

Price / Sq Ft

$436

Property Type

Single Family For Sale

Lot Size

1.2

Class

Property

About This Property

A serene escape nestled on the outskirts of the village, this elegant Old Lyme colonial is an artful blend of historic integrity and contemporary living. Sheltered by a perfect road with little traffic, the four-bedroom, 2750-square-foot residence is on 1.20 acres of beautifully landscaped green and gardens, surrounded by nature and the quiet of the Old Lyme Golf Club. With French doors and a large, historic fireplace commanding center stage, the living room provides generous space for entertaining. The cozy library/family room is a quiet haven for reading or watching your favorite movies. Both chefs and hosts alike will delight in the large open, eat-in dining kitchen, which boasts hand-painted floors, another fireplace, and picturesque views opening out to the terrace, lush gardens, and glamorous pool. Beautiful wooden floors throughout the home add to the timeless appeal and lead you to the stylishly appointed rooms upstairs, including the master suite on the second floor, and three additional bedrooms (the "Zonk Boat Room" with a canopied bed, the Toile Room, and Blue Room). Just 115 miles from New York City or Boston, this house offers a relaxing retreat for country weekends or comfortable year-round living. Close to Old Lyme's village, shopping, art galleries, and museums, this home is a lifestyle choice for those who appreciate privacy, nature, and the classic allure of living chicly with history.

Property Details

25 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme Connecticut 06371 — Single Family For Sale listed at $1,200,000.

At a Glance

4

Bedrooms

4

Bathrooms

2,750

Sq Ft

1.2

Lot Size

--

Garage

1730

Year Built

The Details

Property TypeSingle Family For Sale
NeighborhoodNew London
Address25 Johnny Cake Hill Road
MLS Number24095314
Year Built1730
Square Footage2,750
Lot Size1.2
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms4
Water SourcePrivate Well

Property Details

Other Details

Appliances IncludedMicrowave,Washer,Dryer
Parcel Number1552932
Radon Mitigation Air YNUUnknown
Radon Mitigation Water YNUUnknown
ZoningPer Town

Financial

Assessed Value845000
Mil Rate Total16.23
Property Tax13714
Tax YearJuly 2025-June 2026

Property Features

Attic DescriptionUnfinished,Storage Space,Walk-up
Attic YN1
Basement DescriptionFull,Unfinished,Full With Hatchway
Cooling SystemWindow Unit
Exterior FeaturesPorch,Patio
Exterior SidingShingle
Fireplaces Total2
Foundation TypeConcrete,Stone
Fuel Tank LocationIn Basement
Heat Fuel TypeOil
Heat TypeHot Water
Hot Water DescriptionOil,Domestic,50 Gallon Tank
Interior FeaturesAuto Garage Door Opener,Cable - Available,Security System
Laundry Room InfoLower Level
Pool DescriptionGunite,Spa,Salt Water,In Ground Pool
Roof InformationWood Shingle
Swimming Pool YN1

All Photos (37)

MARKET CONTEXTOld Lyme →
Town Median+124% vs list
$535,000
Old Lyme, CT
Mill Rate
21.45
New London County
NYC Commute
140 min
door-to-door estimate
Schools
A-
1 graded
LOADING COMP CLOUD…

This listing is +124% vs the Old Lyme median. Verify against same-school-district comps before competing offers.

Contact Colette Harron

Fill out the form below and we will respond promptly.

Affordability Calculator

$1,200,000

Down Payment$240,000
Loan Amount$960,000
Principal & Interest$6,068/mo
Property Tax$1,200/mo
Insurance$100/mo
Est. Monthly$7,368/mo

Listing Agent

C

Colette Harron

William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l

Quick Facts

StatusClosed
TypeSingle Family For Sale
ClassProperty
MLS #24095314
Last Updated2026-06-11