NOMADEReal Estate

$1,125,000

Active

34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road

Old Lyme, Connecticut, 06371 · New London County

3

Beds

5

Baths

3,435

Sq Ft

1978

Built

MLS # 24158291

Price / Sq Ft

$328

Property Type

Single Family For Sale

Lot Size

2.03

Class

Property

About This Property

A Bold House, Built for a Bold Life. Intentionally delivering scale, separation, and presence. Comprehensively reimagined in 2021, modern systems, elevated finishes, and a layout designed for lifestyle. The heart of the home is an expansive kitchen and dining space designed to perform. Quartz countertops, custom 42-inch cabinetry with dovetail construction, a dedicated chef's pantry, and Profile GE Series appliances, create a space that is perfect for large gatherings. Large Marvin windows pull natural light throughout the main living areas, highlighting substantial interior doors, and bold millwork. The Primary Suite is positioned intentionally separated for privacy and presence. Gas Fireplace, Walk-in Closet, an Elegant Dressing Room, Spa-Level Bath with Frameless Glass Double Shower, Dual Quartz Vanities, and a Private Water Closet. Secondary bedrooms are generously sized, each with its own full bath, offering autonomy for guests, family, or extended stays. Large additional living spaces provide flexibility- media, recreation, or home office. Hardie-plank siding, all New Roof in 2021, central air with 3 condensers, a newly installed underground propane tank, and leased solar panels support year-round comfort, efficiency, and ease of ownership. Old Lyme offers coastal New England character and cultural depth- beaches, an established arts community, proximity to the Old Lyme Country Club, and convenient access to major transportation routes to New York City and Boston.

Property Details

34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme Connecticut 06371 — Single Family For Sale listed at $1,125,000.

At a Glance

3

Bedrooms

5

Bathrooms

3,435

Sq Ft

2.03

Lot Size

--

Garage

1978

Year Built

The Details

Property TypeSingle Family For Sale
NeighborhoodNew London
Address34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road
MLS Number24158291
Year Built1978
Square Footage3,435
Lot Size2.03
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms5
Water SourcePrivate Well

Property Details

Availability & Terms

Acceptable FinancingFHA,VA
Occupied ByVacant
Possession AvailabilityNegotiable

Other Details

Appliances IncludedGas Cooktop,Wall Oven,Microwave,Range Hood,Refrigerator,Dishwasher,Washer,Dryer
ColorGrey
In Law AccessSecond Floor
In Law ApartmentPossible
Parcel Number1552935
Virtual Tourhttps://my.matterport.com/show/?m=Lhg2m4Y41rm&mls=1
ZoningRU40

Financial

Assessed Value867400
Mil Rate Total16.23
Property Tax14078
Tax YearJuly 2025-June 2026

All Photos (50)

MARKET CONTEXTOld Lyme
Town Median+110% vs list
$535,000
Old Lyme, CT
Mill Rate
21.45
New London County
NYC Commute
140 min
Metro-North express
Schools
A-
1 graded
LOADING COMP CLOUD…

This listing is +110% vs the Old Lyme median. Verify against same-school-district comps before competing offers.

Contact John Roberto

Fill out the form below and we will respond promptly.

Affordability Calculator

$1,125,000

Down Payment$225,000
Loan Amount$900,000
Principal & Interest$5,689/mo
Property Tax$1,125/mo
Insurance$100/mo
Est. Monthly$6,914/mo

Listing Agent

J

John Roberto

CENTURY 21 Shutters & Sails

Quick Facts

StatusActive
TypeSingle Family For Sale
ClassProperty
MLS #24158291
Last Updated2026-05-31

Virtual Tour

Walk through 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road