NOMADEReal Estate

$1,395,000

Active

423 Whalley Avenue

New Haven, Connecticut, 06511 · New Haven County

0

Beds

6

Baths

6,165

Sq Ft

1976

Built

MLS # 24154449

Price / Sq Ft

$226

Property Type

Commercial For Sale

Lot Size

0.25

Class

Property

About This Property

Prime Mixed Use Investment Opportunity in the Heart of New Haven! ***Sale is for the Real Estate only not the business*** Welcome to 423 Whalley Avenue, a well maintained 6 unit mixed use property offering exceptional income potential and strong value add upside. Ideally situated on the corner of Whalley Avenue and Ellsworth Avenue, this 6,100+ sq ft asset features 4 residential apartments and 2 commercial units, currently occupied by the long established Damato's Seafood Restaurant. The residential unit mix includes: * Two (2) - 2BR / 1BA units * One (1) - 3BR / 1BA unit * One (1) - 4BR / 2BA unit (vacant, offering immediate owner user or rent up opportunity) All residential units-aside from the top floor 4BR-are fully occupied, with below market rents providing substantial room for revenue growth. The commercial spaces are fully leased and operating as Damato's Restaurant, a long time neighborhood favorite. Damato's will do a lease back on the space they currently occupy. With a pro forma NOI supporting a potential 7% CAP rate, this property offers both stability and future upside for investors. Additional amenities include a 3 car detached garage, plus a fenced in rear parking lot providing secure parking for tenants and commercial patrons. Whether you're expanding your portfolio or seeking a high performing mixed use asset, 423 Whalley Avenue delivers location, scale, and immediate value add potential in one of New Haven's most active corridors.

Property Details

423 Whalley Avenue, New Haven Connecticut 06511 — Commercial For Sale listed at $1,395,000.

At a Glance

0

Bedrooms

6

Bathrooms

6,165

Sq Ft

0.25

Lot Size

--

Garage

1976

Year Built

The Details

Property TypeCommercial For Sale
NeighborhoodNew Haven
Address423 Whalley Avenue
MLS Number24154449
Year Built1976
Square Footage6,165
Lot Size0.25
Bedrooms0
Bathrooms6
Water SourcePublic Water Connected

Property Details

Financial

Assessed Value441910
Mil Rate Total41.9
Property Tax18516
Tax YearJuly 2025-June 2026

Building Details

Ceiling Height8
Numberof Restrooms5
Numberof Stories3
Sq Ft Residential3965
Sq Ft Retail2200
Sq Ft SourcePublic Records
Total Numberof Units6

Property Features

Cooling SystemCentral Air,Window Unit
Foundation TypeConcrete
Heat Fuel TypeNatural Gas
Heat TypeHot Water
Roof InformationAsphalt Shingle

All Photos (31)

Affordability Calculator

$1,395,000

Down Payment$279,000
Loan Amount$1,116,000
Principal & Interest$7,054/mo
Property Tax$1,395/mo
Insurance$100/mo
Est. Monthly$8,549/mo

Listing Agent

J

Joe Scarpellino

Coldwell Banker Realty

Contact Joe Scarpellino

Fill out the form below and we will respond promptly.

Quick Facts

StatusActive
TypeCommercial For Sale
ClassProperty
MLS #24154449
Last Updated2026-04-30